by Derek Irvine
I was reading a recent Forbes article that discussed the distinction between employees’ authentic engagement versus scripted service in creating an unparalleled customer experience. One quote from that article really jumped out at me. “Of course, this [creating authentic engagement] is more challenging than doing things by rote: challenging for the employee and challenging for the manager.”
This immediately reminded me of a poignant example that we discuss in our book, The Power of Thanks. In one interaction at a Fairmont Hotels & Resorts Rocky Mountain property, a room attendant overheard the children of a guest ask about roasting marshmallows in the room’s fireplace. When the family returned to the room later in the day, they found a basket of s’more ingredients and a handwritten note from the employee saying, “Because we know how much you like marshmallows.” A quote from Fairmont’s executive leadership captures the challenge of developing that kind of behavior across the company: “You can’t engineer that kind of creativity.” Why is it so hard? Here are three reasons:
Challenge 1 (for Employees): Moving Beyond Scripted Service
It isn’t difficult to see how “doing things by rote” would be the easier path from the employee perspective – service that involves making sure that the room is clean and towels are stocked. But even if performed to the highest levels, these services wouldn’t have nearly the sticking power for this family or for the organization. Creating authentic engagement on the other hand, is much more impactful but also more difficult to achieve and sustain. For the employee, work becomes much more than the job being performed. It involves not only being open to opportunities like the one above and being prepared to engage the customer, but also in having the support of the organization to behave in those creative and authentic ways. In the case of the Fairmont room attendant, it was being attentive to the guests’ experience during their stay and being prepared to deliver a little extra to make the experience even better.
Challenge 2 (for Managers): Supporting Individual Creativity and Authenticity
As the executive notes above, management’s challenge lies in nurturing that kind of individual creativity and authenticity across the entire organization. There isn’t a policy or manual that will work for that or even other similar situations. The solution instead lies in developing a solution to recognize these types of moments, integrating them into the company culture and values over time. Managers also need to be sure they attract, select, and retain employees who want to make those types of moments happen. Still, the challenge may be somewhat easier in the hospitality and other customer-facing industries, where an employees-first mindset drives superior customer experiences through authentic engagement.
Challenge 3 (for Everyone): Enhancing the Impact of Work through Meaningful Interaction
So does this distinction matter for groups or companies that are not primarily customer-facing? As Adam Grant (of Give and Take fame) said in this Knowledge@Wharton article: “Everyone has an end user.” That brings us to a third, broader challenge to authentic engagement, which is identifying who that end user is and opening lines of communication and interaction between the two. Research summarized by the Wharton article mentioned above suggests that employees who know how their work is meaningful to the beneficiary of that work are both happier and more productive than employees who lack that line of sight.
Recognition really helps create these lines of sight on several fronts. Let address each challenge in turn, building from the bottom up. First, recognition allows beneficiaries to reach out directly to the people whose contributions were helpful to them, resulting in increased happiness and productivity. Second, the behaviors and ultimately data generated by employees recognizing each other gives managers a powerful tool to help sustain the types of creative behaviors that stem from authentic engagement. Finally, employees are able to see and learn from vivid examples of others’ engagement, expanding their own repertoires of creative behaviors, so that they are ready and supported when opportunity knocks.
Do you remember a time when you were on the giving or receiving end of an authentically engaged moment at work? How did you go about recognizing that moment?
About Derek Irvine
The VP of Client Strategy and Consulting at Globoforce, Derek Irvine is one of the world’s foremost experts on employee recognition and engagement, helping business leaders set a higher vision and ambition for their organizations. As a renowned speaker and co-author of "The Power of Thanks" and "Winning with a Culture of Recognition," he teaches companies how to use recognition to proactively manage company culture. Derek holds a B.Comm and Masters of Business Studies from the Smurfit Graduate Business School at University College Dublin.